Property Insurance on the Rise?

January 22, 2021 | By chad siemer
Property insurance on the rise

I’ve seen posts on neighborhood social media groups and pages such as Facebook and Nextdoor from homeowners asking if others have seen their home insurance rates go up dramatically this year. This is a trend that appears to be happening statewide and the real estate industry is taking note.

There are many factors that play a role in insurance rate increases such as weather events, population changes, home type, proximity to hazards, previous claim on the home or by the homeowner, claims from other homeowners in your area, and even the price and availability of reinsurance.

But lawmakers and insurance officials alike are grappling with the double-digit rate increases we have been seeing. And when homeowners are no longer able to buy a policy on the private market they turn to Citizens Property Insurance. The overall health of the property insurance market is often reflected in the number of homeowners getting coverage from Citizens, which was created as an insurer of last resort.

The number of Citizens policies ballooned after the 2004 and 2005 hurricane seasons and had 1.47 million policies in 2011. Many programs were created that aimed to shift customers to private insurers, Citizens’ policy numbers were lessened to 427,000 policies in 2018. But as the private market worsened, the count went to 532,000 policies in 2020 and according to Floridarealtors.org, is projected to increase to 630,000 policies or more this year.

“I have not seen any evidence that the trends we are seeing now are going to reverse,” said Fla. Insurance Commission Altmaier says, referring to double-digit homeowner’s policy rate increases and the greater number of policies in Citizens.

Another theory behind the increase is the increased number of property claims that are not coming from the homeowners, but rather solicitors. Many insurance-industry officials, regulators and lawmakers contend that the property-insurance system is plagued by excessive litigation and questionable claims.

“These don’t appear to be normal roofing claims in which a consumer notices that they’ve had a loss and calls their insurance companies, but instead solicitations,” Altmaier said.

But Sen. Annette Taddeo, D-Miami, asked Altmaier what the state is doing to prevent potentially fraudulent roofing claims.

“Wouldn’t that be fraud, and what are we doing to go after what I would call bad roofers?” she asked.

Seemingly questioning the arguments about excessive litigation, Sen. Darryl Rouson, D-St. Petersburg, also asked whether regulators had “been able to detect any trends or patterns on the part of insurance companies, carriers, that have indicated bad conduct or low-balling or anything like that.”

Altmaier said regulators have looked at such issues after hurricanes.

“So far our findings do not indicate that we have any kind of systemic, market-wide approach by insurance carriers that would indicate that they are low-balling claims or things of that nature,” Altmaier said. “Based on the information that I have seen; it seems more as if the disputes arise from whether or not there actually is a covered loss.”

Sen. Doug Broxson, R-Gulf Breeze, said the state is always going to have “bad behavior,” but the insurance market is on an unsustainable course in which consumers won’t be able to afford premiums.

“The simple question we have today is what are we willing to do,” Broxson said. “What are we willing to do as a Legislature to protect all the consumers, not the ones that benefit temporarily from getting a roof or getting a new kitchen, but all those others that are paying the premium. And the debate is simply, who are we here to protect?”

Featured Properties

Sorry we are experiencing system issues. Please try again.
View ALL

what our customers say!

Sold our home in less than 3 weeks and above asking price. Will be using him again to sell our other home in the very near future. You wont be disappointed in selecting Chuck and his team, I recommend you start packing once you bring him on board.


Kyla helped me find my perfect home. She was helpful, knowledgeable, and most importantly, she listened to my wants and needs! We searched until we found my perfect home. She stayed on top of the inspections and mortgage broker requirements until closing day. I could not have chosen a better  partner for my home search. Thank you, Kyla! You are a rock star and I could not be happier.


Chuck is just the best! So friendly, helpful and quite the funny guy 🙂 we loved him ?? and after all of our shenanigans, house to house to house to house……he was so patient and would even tell us if he thought we were in over our head. Sometimes we saw “a little fix here and there” but chuck  saw a headache! He’s not in it for a quick sale! That’s why, we’re going to buy another house! We purchased our house a little over a year ago but we’re ready to move on….I’ll be call you soon Chuck!

Jess & Colin

Words can never express how much I enjoyed and loved working with Kyla. For me, I never wanted to work with a realtor due to fears of them scamming me and just “talking a good game”. Kyla eased that fear the very first time we met. She was personable and she answered questions in a way that made  you actually answer your own questions in order for you to be the sole driver of the process while she copiloted and snatched the wheel when need be. Lol. She was available when needed most and very understanding when questions came up in the wee hours of the night. Would I recommend her, ABSOLUTELY!! Kyla thank you again for all that you’ve done for my family and I! YOU ROCK!


Kyla was excellent. She was very kind & understanding. The closing on my home was a mess! Everything that could go wrong, did go wrong. Kayla sat with me the entire day at the closing office waiting for a wire transfer. She made a difficult day much easier for me. The purchase of my new home was  swift & easy bc of her. She also made sure that I won the bid on my new home with a secret she uses, as there were 5 offers!! I would highly recommend her to anyone buying or selling.


Chuck was everything you could ask for in a realtor – smart, responsive, thorough and genuinely kind and honest. After meeting with other realtors, we were so happy we went with Chuck. He really listened to us, gave us sage advice and made the selling process a breeze. Doesn’t get better than that!


contact us

get in touch